wp-openid - faster, stronger, better

One of the primary focuses for this next major release of wp-openid is stability. While most people have had great success with the plugin, there are a fair number that seem to have all kinds of strange problems, ranging from conflicts with other plugins, data corruption, library issues, etc. In order to reach the level of adoption I’d love to see, we have to make this plugin as easy to install and run as WordPress itself. This is certainly no easy task, but we’ve come a very long way. To this end, you’ll find the following changes:

Simplified Database Structure

Version 1.0 of wp-openid added four new database tables and overloaded one of the comment table fields in a weird way. Version 2.0 required only three of those four tables and added one column to the comment table to eliminate the overloaded field. The current development version doesn’t add any columns or overload fields of existing tables, and adds only one new table of its own, which I’m still hoping to eliminate.

The two removed tables were used to store OpenID associations and nonces, both of which are temporary data necessary to make OpenID security actually work. Instead of using these tables, I’ve opted to use an updated version of the OpenID store used in Simon Willison’s mu-open-id plugin which uses the WordPress options table to store this data. I’ve updated his store to use the latest php-openid APIs as well as to reduce the potential for race conditions.

I’ve removed the column from the comments table that was tracking which comments were left using OpenIDs, and am instead storing this in the postmeta table for the post the comment is associated with. It would certainly be preferable to have a commentmeta table, but I like this better than the previous solution.

The one remaining table is the identity table which tracks the identity URLs of each user. I would like to store this in the usermeta table, but because it requires unique keys there’s just not a real clean way to do this and keep the plugin scalable to support large deployments. If this is fixed in 2.7, we could theoretically eliminate any custom database stuff in the plugin, which I’d absolutely love.

Removed PEAR_LOG

For the time being I’ve removed PEAR_LOG and am simply using error_log() for what logging still remains. The problem is that most people weren’t taking advantage of the logs anyway, so they were just taking up space. I’ll likely look at making use of the WP_DEBUG constant to allow more verbose logging when it’s desired. For now this just simplifies things a bit, and eliminates at least one case of library conflict that was reported.

Code Refactoring

Really? More refactoring? Didn’t I just do a lot of this in the last point release? Well yes, but more was needed… MUCH more. Previously, code was roughly divided based on the MVC (model, view, controller) model into store.php, interface.php, and logic.php, respectively. That worked for a while, but got to be pretty confusing as those individual files became a bit unmanageable. Instead, things are now broken into more logical segments… comments, admin panel, logging in through wp-login.php, etc. This seems to be a lot easier to manage and more importantly, easier to extend.

More Hooks

I haven’t sat down to document them all yet, but I’m adding in more hooks for other plugins to add functionality. Want to pull profile data from FOAF instead of sreg? No problem, now you have a hook you can implement. This makes everything in the plugin much more lightweight and “loosely joined” which is always good. All of the existing non-core OpenID functionality (like SREG) is currently using these hooks.

Bug Fixes

Though I’m not always good about replying, I generally do monitor the conversations on the WordPress support forums. I will try and put together a more exhaustive list of what bugs have been addressed, but I will simply say for now that most of the major bugs people have reported there should be absent from the current development branch.

Comments and responses

[…] wp-openid - faster, stronger, better Will Norris (creator of wp-openid, the WordPress plugin many folks use to manage OpenID logins on their blogs) writes “One of the primary focuses for this next major release of wp-openid is stability. While most people have had great success with the plugin, there are a fair number that seem to have all kinds of strange problems, ranging from conflicts with other plugins, data corruption, library issues, etc. In order to reach the level of adoption I’d love to see, we have to make this plugin as easy to install and run as WordPress itself. This is certainly no easy task, but we’ve come a very long way.” […]
Want to pull profile data from FOAF instead of sreg?

Is this something we can hook into nicely from wp-diso-profile for importing hCards, instead of the hacky “first log in, import URL if they have one” method we have now?

[quote comment=“25011”]Is this something we can hook into nicely from wp-diso-profile for importing hCards, instead of the hacky “first log in, import URL if they have one” method we have now?[/quote]

Absolutely. We may need to add one additional hook in another place, but this should certainly be doable.

[quote comment=“25166”]Will you drop IDIP support for wp-openid 3.0? You disabled the XRDS-Code and renamed the OpenID input-fields…[/quote] Oops… I think I was testing some XRDS-Simple stuff when I commented that out. It will definitely be in the final 3.0 release. The OpenID input fields where updated to be consistent with the 2.0 spec, and either will work with IDIB.

Partly a test, partly here to say that this is an awesome plugin. I went looking for something to give OpenID functionality to my wordpress blog and came across this. Sadly, for now the only openID I’ve gotten to work is my flickr account. Not sure why that is, whenever I login to other openID sites it just redirects me back to my site without a comment. It does the same on other sites I’ve tested too.

I’m sure you’ve heard about this issue before, I just hope it’s fixed come next release! I wanted to be able to delegate my own openID, excited about that feature being added. Keep up the good work!

[…] It’s worth mentioning that pretty much all of the new features require that you also have the XRDS-Simple plugin installed. There are also a number of other changes in regards to simplifying and stabilizing the plugin, than can be read about here. […]